Electric-assist?

19 posts / 0 new
Last post
durior
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-03
Country: Israel
Electric-assist?

not necessarily right now, but is there a forecast/policy? something light, to help on climbs...?

josh.hon
Offline
Team Tern
Joined: 2011-08-01
Country: Taiwan

We believe in electric bikes for certain types of riders, so yes, expect to see one in our future.

dovidhalevi
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-10
Country: Israel

Second the motion. I have electric-assisted Vitesse 7 and like this very much. Still can get exercise but get there quicker, less swetted up.

The Freedom-ebikes kit is only 3.2 kg. This is practical for such a light-weight bicycle. The other kits, maybe prettier packages, are 6-7 kg which make little sense for a 12kg bike. The battery may be smaller than some but if more range be needed, there is the option of buying a second 1kg battery for use in parallel or (as Trek recommends--much cheaper) a second charger to keep at work. One only needs to widen the fork a bit (steel-only!) to fit the wider wheel with hub-motor. The motor has a freewheel so the bike rides as it was when motor is not being used.

Of course, a bike built for assist, has more options such as more standard-width forks for hub-motors or a chain drive (some argue more efficient over wider speed ranges) such as on the Boost. While built-in electric bikes tend to be single-speed or maybe 3 gears, I like having all 7 on my Vitesse. There is no law I have to use the motor all the time and I can still get up the hill on pedal power if I choose (or if the battery is empty).

durior
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-03
Country: Israel

I too got a freedomEbike kit.

I think that Tern (I admit, started to type D...) should do the great research and design job they do, and think the E thing over:

* I'm not sure front hub is better than rear hub or chain-driving motor

* maybe the fork width discrepancy can be resolved, so aluminum bikes can use it too

* for electric-assist, there should be an emphasis on the bike's behavior when motor is off: should have nearly same roll resistance as regular hub.

* since motor speed is limited, some indication that speed was reached would be good (to save on battery; my 13km ride uses it up to the last drop sometimes; and if I'd have better indication along the way, that too would help me manage my battery power)

Enginator
Enginator's picture
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-10
Country: USA

Warning this response refers to another brand of electric bicycle but is not an endorsement and certainly does not suggest that Tern will not market a better product when they offer pedelecs! I know Tern's will be better.

Check out Prodeco Technologies. They appear to be using some DaHon patents for the frame, bars etc and they have OK components except they only have 24V to date. A 36V model is coming. [Correction they now have the Phantom X which offers 36V]. Keeping their price on most models under $1000 is brilliant. They will sell well. It even looks as if constructing a folder that could be "suitcased" might be feasible using the DaHon style fold.

I have built several PEDELECS and 36V is far superior. My personal pedelec used to get to work without being sweaty uses a Heinzmann, German front hub and pulse width modulated control. Works great. I actually use 38.5V of battery which increase my range about 4-5 miles to 25 miles.

www.prodecotech.com

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LP9xjnQXMR0&feature=related

I know the cunning guys and gals at Tern will do it better when they do market a electric assist product so it could be well worth waiting. Meanwhile a kit could get you by. Prodeco has them. I hope they offer 36V soon. Correction they now offer a 36V Phantom X

 

__________________

Slim Chasteen,

 Promoting Bicycling for over 50 years!

 Bicycling Expert Witness and Shop Owner

Speed P8 with Bike Friday Samsonite trailer case for air travel. Still considering which is best Tern for hard case travel

dovidhalevi
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-10
Country: Israel

These look nice but weigh a ton. Tern will definitely do it better when they indeed take the plunge. Prodecotek has kept the price in line so that is a very nice start! Availability outside the USA may be questionable right now.

More on their models:

Their hub motor-wheels require a 100mm fork. OK for standard full sized bikes but most 20" folders will not enable this. The Freedomebike has an 80mm model for folders and both sizes use 36v (39.6v) 250w motors. Motor and one battery are 3.3kg.

Their forks are aluminum. Most ebike kits discourage this  (I am not talking about the need to stretch them apart for the wider motor). I trust that they are using torque arm reinforcements as need be so the aluminum is OK.

dovidhalevi
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-10
Country: Israel

durior ha scritto:

I too got a freedomEbike kit.

I think that Tern (I admit, started to type D...) should do the great research and design job they do, and think the E thing over:

* I'm not sure front hub is better than rear hub or chain-driving motor

* maybe the fork width discrepancy can be resolved, so aluminum bikes can use it too

* for electric-assist, there should be an emphasis on the bike's behavior when motor is off: should have nearly same roll resistance as regular hub.

* since motor speed is limited, some indication that speed was reached would be good (to save on battery; my 13km ride uses it up to the last drop sometimes; and if I'd have better indication along the way, that too would help me manage my battery power)

Rear hub would place the propulsion under your weight so should be better and would also integrate better with regenerative braking and "pedelec" schemes. However, this is more difficult to install and supply as an aftermarked kit. The cassette (no more room for hub-gears, etc.) must fit as well or be supplied with the kit. The chain drive, because of the lower speed range of the chain should yield better torque over a wider range of bike speed using the gears. However, such a motor needs be internally geared down, more weight, and installing this would be more difficult on a compact folder. Might be best idea for a designed-in bike if the weight can be kept within reason.

D... vehemently justifies their narrow fork and narrow hubs and their wheels are indeed a work of art. Admittedly, this restricts user upgrades.

Freedomebike motors have a freewheel so do not (should not) effect the bike when not in use. Kits incorporating regenerative braking make this much more complicated.

Electric motors work like this: They pull the most current and offer the most torque when ... locked (this is how they are often rated). Once the motor begins to turn (whether I turn it or the battery does), it also works as a generator, producing a current oposing the motion (Lenz's law, i.e. no perpetual motion). The faster it turns, the more Lenz's law current. So the actual current drawn by the motor and its torque decreases (why the chain drive can be better). At maximum speed, current drain is way down and so is torque. I have found, however, that my motor performs fine at most speeds I use.

To increase range, use less "throttle" and pedal! This way, the motor, if used, remains at lower speeds  for less time. I rarely use the motor on level ground except if I need a little more umph to get out of a spot quicker. This is an electric-assist for a bike, not an all-electric scooter (you can get these as well, but with much larger, heavier batteries). 13km in moderate usage is not an unreasonable range. Alternatives are to use an added battery (just 1kg but costly) or keep a spare charger at work (cheap).

Indigo
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-02
Country: Romania

A very interesting idea about pedelec: http://www.pedelecs.co.uk/content.php?r=456-Stephen-Britt-talks-to-Pedel...

No front or rear hub motor, no drivetrain motor - just electric pedal. A totally different approach :D . I like the ideea a lot

I think that currently there are many sources of inspiration for Tern - to get somethink totally new to e-bike - since the interest to e-bike / pedelec are increasing.

I'll wait with a big interest to see what will be your approach for an (folding) e-bike (or maybe more e-bike types)

Congratulation for the Eurobike award on your Eclipse

 

dovidhalevi
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-10
Country: Israel

This is pretty ingenious indeed! Limitations I see are that the motors which need be small also need to be internally geared for the slow revs. And since the batteries must also be contained, their size is quite limited.

josh.hon
Offline
Team Tern
Joined: 2011-08-01
Country: Taiwan

Thanks for the ideas. We’ve got something pretty interesting in the works but its not for a year or two yet. We’re rolling stuff out very slowly – only after a long period of testing.

Indigo
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-02
Country: Romania

Hi Josh,

sory to came back again, I hope you don't mind.

I just want to be sure you've noticed this ideea http://senseable.mit.edu/copenhagenwheel/

It seems very interesting for me - I don't know how it appears to you - and how feasible is the ideea.

But I've mentioned of some point (in a different topic) the ideea to change a wheel (and attach a battery) and voila - you have an electric.

The above ideea seems to follow (partially) this principle

 

Best regards

 

thor
thor's picture
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-01
Country: USA

this is a slick webpage.... more slick 3 d cad drawings ..... and also a "working" sample even ....


Remember the dot com years.... that would have gotten youlisted on wallstreet, investors would have lined up in drones and the "inventor" would have been millinaer over night ....


 


Today, however is different, mock up samples arnt enough, slick websites arnt enough, an idea which will work only on one type of bicycle aint enough, if the marketing is too slick most people start running ( me included ) ...


 


Its gonna be a bear to move that wheel, with batteries, motor, and and and in it... remember its rotating weight you are carrying around. People pay 30 dlr more for a Schwalbe tire which weighs a mere 50 grams less for that reason !!! Now think you gonna put a 20 lbs wheel into the back of the bike !!!


Its a good idea somehow, but "can do" way to much things for my taste ..most likely nothing real good ...


But I have eaten my words before


 


thor


p.s. it doesnt fit in my 20 inch bike..... the spokes will never live more than 100 miles ..... Why do they think they have to reinvent the wheel? Suspicious ! EuroEngeneeering ?

__________________

www.ThorUSA.com               Tern: Its all about the ride            Dahon: Freedom unfolds

Indigo
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-02
Country: Romania

Hi Thor,

Thank you for notice so accurate what are the main problems of this project.

Of course I didn't expect for Josh or someone else to pick up an already made up fancy e-bike component and just add it to an already made bike. I just want to make Josh or someone else to think to other ways getting around. And maybe just to make the same e-thing better or more appealing. Of course - maybe I dare too much - but hey - this is just a try. I strongly believe that the future is not of those who want to keep walking to the same old paths - but for those who are willing to take new technological challenges and integrate in their products.

Even I can't afford (for the moment), I like Tern bikes a lot - they are a fresh air on the folding market - but as I said in a different topic, I would like much more a "convertible e - Tern bike". The above idea is just an idea going one step in a direction which it happens to like - and nothing more. By the way - it is possible to achieve a production license for it - so I believe that it's not just a cad drawing and an experiment. I believe that those who made the project have not thought to a particular bike (of course - folding bikes are not the intended target) like they said, cite: "It transforms ordinary bicycles quickly into hybrid e-bikes that also function as mobile sensing units". Since this is an already made project I believe that they overcome in one way or another - the problems you've just enumerated

There are many ideas out there - and probably most of them will never evolve in a production phase, since the profit rules. but looking in the past - some revolutionary idea like the plane, car and even bicycles - had their contestants at their time. Though ... looking at the present time we all have traveling with modern cars (and electric cars?), modern aircraft and beautifully (e) bikes.

Also - if you are looking to the bike market, almost every major player in the field has started entering in the e-bike field with some dedicated models - specially designed for electric assist. And not only - some car manufacturers have started to create (and sell in 2012?) - see Smart, Toyota, and Peugeot some e-bikes which complements their electric urban cars. I believe this trend will grow up in the future.

Of course - this is just an opinion - feel free to comment

All the best

Indigo
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-02
Country: Romania

<the comment gets duplicated - so I've deleted>

<maybe a delete button can be usefull>

Thanks

Indigo
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-02
Country: Romania

thor ha scritto:

p.s. it doesnt fit in my 20 inch bike..... the spokes will never live more than 100 miles ..... Why do they think they have to reinvent the wheel? Suspicious ! EuroEngeneeering ?

I've noticed you're post script (bold) - this is the second time you are making some subtle remarks to the europe. See this topic: http://www.ternbicycles.com/forum/just-wish

where you said, cite:

"Winning a Eurobike award being an Euro Company .... is usually a little easier than just by merits alone".

Do you have a problem with euro zone? You know - there are many inventions discovered here in Europe

I just wondering

 

Regards

 

josh.hon
Offline
Team Tern
Joined: 2011-08-01
Country: Taiwan

Indigo – I’m sure Thor doesn’t mean anything with the Euro comments, especially since he’s German/American and speaks perfect German. Personally, I think the most interesting bike innovations are coming out of Europe because the people there are really using bikes for transport. I love amazing things like the Schmidt dynamo hub, Ortlieb bags, KlickFix attachments – the innovations here are much more interesting to me than the latest and greatest 5” travel suspension fork.

Indigo
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-02
Country: Romania

Thank you for clarification Josh.

I din't want to harm anyone with my observations

I'll look further for Tern bicycles

 

Best wishes

thor
thor's picture
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-01
Country: USA

Hi Indigo


being from Europe originally , working with European companies , I might have a heightened sense, and the right to critize, the same way we get critized from Europe over here. Obviously , sometimes I am plain flat wrong with my opinion. But than I am the first to admit and ready to learn .... which just might be the American part in me....lol


Have to agree with Josh about most of the bike stuff I really like is originating from Europe. ( just look on my website, which makes this perfectly clear, where my heart is )  It seems that in Europe there is more emphasise on regular people ( including old farts like me )  using their bike, than over here, where you need the latest "Madonne" to ride around in circles, or the 9 inch front dual travel downhiller to ride in some crazy locations, with drops high as skyscrapers.... ( sorry I am too afraid to do THAT)


But that doesnt stop me for being skeptical about slick, reinvent the wheel , revolutionizing the industry, kind of products.


The above mentioned wheel is solely designed for singlespeed ( yuppi ) bikes.... at a time where more and more hastily formed Singlespeed speed companies are folding( going out of business)........not the good folding ..lol   


I have used, sold, repaired, customized a couple of Bionix folders, Dahon original versions, and a couple Internet wonders, over the years. The Bionix is the Cadillac with all bells and whistles, but not without a challenge or two either. I am waiting for the new Sram concept, which will be a little more KISS ( Keep it simple stupid) ..... Sram being an US company but these ideas are definitely coming from Europe,,,, I would bet .... where they have 1000 times the experience with e bikes than over here .....


 


Peace Thor


 


 

__________________

www.ThorUSA.com               Tern: Its all about the ride            Dahon: Freedom unfolds

Indigo
Offline
Joined: 2011-08-02
Country: Romania

Well, far from me to go to a comparison between Europe / USA - regarding who invented and what. Both have significant inventions.

I don't know you personally Thor (I've only saw you on youtube) - and indeed - maybe you have rights to criticize the European companies - since, as I see, you know them much better than me.

But I guess it is not normal for European to criticize US and vice versa. Such an attitude it is not benefic for anybody.

Of course - I have nothing do to with you. I just believe that comments on the forum are better to be neutral.

Regarding the wheel - as I said above - I just liked the idea and wanted to share on this forum. But like already Josh let us to understand - this will not be a direction Tern will follow (at least for the moment). I guess this is not the most appropriate place to discuss new ideea but more appropriate to discuss Tern stuff (which I guess is the right thing to do). So I'll conform to this direction in the future

Peace be also with you
Indigo

PS: you have some interesting stuff on your site.

Login or register to post comments